1DCA
MONTH: April 2006
To view full document click on case number (document in .pdf format)
Number Style Per Curiam Disposition Date Issued
02-0165 DERRICK SMITH v. STATE OF FLORIDA 4/12/2006
02-2833 CHARLES MALLORY VAUGHT v. GAYLE KENDALL, in Re: Guardianship/Estate of: Gladys Celestine Vaught, Deceased AFFIRMED 4/20/2006
02-3953 DEWAYNE COOPER v. FLORIDA DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTIONS DISMISSED 4/27/2006
03-4587 TERRANCE D. GOODMAN v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 4/28/2006
04-2202 JOHN D. MORROW v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 4/19/2006
04-2907 MARK SHERWOOD v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 4/24/2006
04-3099 VICTOR SCONIERS v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 4/20/2006
04-4632 PAULETTE RUTLAND, as Personal Representative of the ESTATE OF MATTHEW ROBERT PRITCHARD, Deceased v. FLASH FOODS, INC., a foregin corporation AFFIRMED 4/6/2002
04-5041 BARBARA POWERS  v. WALT DISNEY WORLD AND WALT DISNEY WORLD WORKERS' COMPENSATION AFFIRMED 4/13/2006
04-5096 DONALD PERRY v. LAKE CITY MEDICAL CENTER, et al. AFFIRMED 4/24/2006
04-5280 ERVIN JACKSON v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 4/27/2006
04-5410 JOSEPH A. PEPIN v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 4/5/2006
04-5531 ANGELA M. PISANI-JONES v. DEREK KENNEDY n/k/a DEREK MULDER AFFIRMED 4/20/2006
04-5573 BERNARD C. McGEE v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 4/27/2006
05-0024 MELVIN ANTHONY JOINER  v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 4/4/2006
05-0027 ALVIN A. THURMAN v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 4/6/2002
05-0150 DONALD L. THOMAS v. JAMES R. McDONOUGH, Secretary AFFIRMED 4/24/2006
05-0237 DAVID LEVELLE JONES v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 4/19/2006
05-0241 DAVID LEVELLE JONES v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 4/20/2006
05-0333 CHOUPIETE PIERRE CASSEUS v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 4/20/2006
05-0393 EDDIE L. WHITE v. MCCRORY BUILDING CO.,/ST. PAUL INSURANCE CO. AFFIRMED 4/6/2002
05-0462 OLGA RODRIGUEZ v. HYATT HOTEL & RESORT GALLAGHER BASSETT SERVICES, INC. 4/12/2006
05-0497 WALTER LEE CHANEY v. JAMES R. McDONOUGH, Secretary, Florida Department of Corrections 4/12/2006
05-0552 JOSEPH L. EMMITE v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 4/21/2006
05-0693 ERSKINE JEROME WARE  v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 4/4/2006
05-0856 LOWELL BERNHEIMER, as  NOT FINAL UNTIL TIME EXPIRES TO
Personal Representative of the  FILE MOTION FOR REHEARING AND
Estate of Lailanie Malay   DISPOSITION THEREOF IF FILED.
Bernheimer, deceased,  and EMILIA
ABISTADO, as Personal Representative
of the Estate of Elaiza Abistado,
deceased v. THE CITY OF JACKSONVILLE		 AFFIRMED 4/20/2006
05-0897 BILLY CLAYTON  v. SMITHFIELD/LYKES MEAT PACKING DIVISION AND TRAVELERS INSURANCE COMPANY AFFIRMED 4/4/2006
05-0910 DOUGLAS M. JACKSON, pro se; REGINALD JORDAN, pro se; BORIS McKINNEY, pro se; and ANTONIO JOHNSON, pro se v. JAMES R. McDONOUGH, Secretary, FLORIDA DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTIONS AFFIRMED 4/27/2006
05-0911 THERESA A. CASEY v. FLORIDA UNEMPLOYMENT APPEALS COMMISSION and ORANGE BLOSSOM RETIREMENT, INC. AFFIRMED 4/21/2006
05-0975 STEVEN FIELDS v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 4/28/2006
05-1009 KEVIN MOORE  v.  JAMES R. MCDONOUGH, STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 4/28/2006
05-1113 JEROME BRINSON v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 4/27/2006
05-1114/05-2315 AMERIGAS EAGLE PROPANE LP d/b/a AMERIGAS PROPANE v. FLORIDA DEPARTMENT OF AGRICULTURE AND CONSUMER SERVICES AFFIRMED 4/24/2006
05-1118 RHONDA KAYE ELLIS v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 4/27/2006
05-1129 KERRA GEORGE  v. PALM BEACH COUNTY SCHOOL DISTRICT AND F. A. RICHARD & ASSOCIATES, INC., AFFIRMED 4/4/2006
05-1173 MICHAEL FIORELLA v. FLORIDA UNEMPLOYMENT APPEALS COMMISSION and HOMETOWN AMERICA MANAGEMENT LLC. AFFIRMED 4/20/2006
05-1203 DEPARTMENT OF HIGWAYS SAFETY AND MOTOR VEHICLES v. ANNA HOYT VERNER DENIED 4/19/2006
05-1208 AKEEM MUHAMMAD   v.  PAUL DECKER AFFIRMED 4/13/2006
05-1303 SHADRICK NORTON  v.  STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 4/10/2006
05-1304 JEROME NELSON  v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 4/4/2006
05-1338 ANDREA OTLEY  v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 4/13/2006
05-1423 ROCK ALAN CROWDER v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 4/19/2006
05-1499 CARLOS COLSTON v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 4/20/2006
05-1584 HORTENSIA HERNANDEZ v. PALM BEACH COUNTY SCHOOL BOARD and F.A. RICHARD & ASSOCIATES AFFIRMED 4/6/2002
05-1640 JAMES WHELLER v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 4/21/2006
05-1667 VANESSA RAE DEKLE and BEVERLY JANE MINCEY, as temporary administrators of the Estate of Raymond K. Mincey AFFIRMED 4/20/2006
05-1673 RICHARD STARKS v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 4/19/2006
05-1708 JHEMAR WILLIAMS v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 4/26/2006
05-1744 GREG GEHRIS v. FLORIDA UNEMPLOYMENT APPEALS COMMISSION AFFIRMED 4/6/2002
05-1780 DENNIS R. BAKER v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 4/24/2006
05-1782 MARCUS HOLMES v. FLORIDA PAROLE COMMISSION DENIED 4/20/2006
05-1810 DIANE E. DARSEY v. FLORIDA UNEMPLOYMENT APPEALS COMMISSION and ORCHIDS BY KNIGHT INC. AFFIRMED 4/21/2006
05-1894 JERRY COOKS v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 4/19/2006
05-1898 LONIE COLEMAN, SR. v. ADVANCED MASONRY SYSTEM and JOHNS EASTERN COMPANY, INC. AFFIRMED 4/24/2006
05-1973 CATRINA D. BRYANT v. GLENMOOR HEALTH CENTER and ROYAL & SUN ALLIANCE AFFIRMED 4/20/2006
05-2007 CURTIS DUGGAN  v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 4/13/2006
05-2028 JAMES R. ERVIN v. DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTIONS and PERC AFFIRMED 4/21/2006
05-2056 SHEMEIKA JOHNSON v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 4/28/2006
05-2064 KEYON HICKS v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 4/21/2006
05-2087 PIGGLY WIGGLY MID SOUTH, INC. and KEMPER INSURANCE COMPANIES v. GWEN MATHENY AFFIRMED 4/6/2002
05-2130 ANTONIO ANTHONY v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 4/28/2006
05-2211 ROBIN L. BRYANT  v. DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTIONS AND PUBLIC EMPLOYEES RELATIONS COMMISSION AFFIRMED 4/13/2006
05-2241 SYLVESTER MARTIN v. STATE OF FLORIDA 4/12/2006
05-2246/05-3560 CYNTHIA ANN DAVIS, former wife v. HORACE JEWEL, III, former husband AFFIRMED 4/27/2006
05-2318 OMAR FRANKLIN BARNES v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 4/19/2006
05-2342 CALVIN HARRITY v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 4/28/2006
05-2387 ISIAH BROWN  v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 4/4/2006
05-2434 GERALD FRANCIS GILLIS, JR. v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 4/19/2006
05-2450 ORVEL WINSTON LLOYD  v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 4/13/2006
05-2524 ZACHARY D. HOLMES v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 4/28/2006
05-2559 FONALIE COLAS v. LABOR FINDERS and AIG CLAIM SERVICE, INC. AFFIRMED 4/19/2006
05-2583 NICHOLAS BRUIJN  v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 4/10/2006
05-2586 TERRY LEE FADDIS v. FLORIDA DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTIONS, FLORIDA PAROLE COMMISSION DENIED 4/28/2006
05-2595 JOHN D. MELVIN  v. AMERICAN EMPLOYEE LEASING/ROYAL SUNALLIANCE AND TMG STAFFING/CNA (f/k/a) RSKCO AFFIRMED 4/10/2006
05-2606 CHRISTOPHER S. ALCORN v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 4/28/2006
05-2607 SIERRA CLUB and ST. JOHNS RIVERKEEPER, INC. v. ST. JOHNS RIVER WATER MANAGEMENT DISTRICT and FLORIDA HOMEBUILDERS ASSOCIATION AFFIRMED 4/5/2006
05-2640 D.N.M., in the interest of: C.G., a Minor Child v. DEPARTMENT OF CHILDREN AND FAMILIES AFFIRMED 4/26/2006
05-2672 JOSE GALVEN BUNI v. STATE OF FLORIDA 4/12/2006
05-2685 ANNIE R. HENDRIX v. FLORIDA UNEMPLOYMENT APPEALS COMMISSION and CRESTVIEW HOSPITAL CORP. AFFIRMED 4/21/2006
05-2718 ANTHONY LAMB  v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 4/10/2006
05-2722 WILLIAM THOMAS BEDWELL v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 4/19/2006
05-2724 DEWAYNE ROBINSON v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 4/26/2006
05-2745 DONALD K. OSTERBYE v. SMITH, THOMPSON, SHAW & MANAUSA, P.A., a Florida professional association; HOUSEHOLD INTERNATIONAL, INC., a Delaware corporation, as successor in interest to TRANSAMERICA FINANCIAL SERVICES, INC.,
 AFFIRMED 4/6/2002
05-2776 JONATHAN STEELE v. STATE OF FLORIDA DISMISSED 4/19/2006
05-2778/05-2780 ROBERT ALAN COSTELLO v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 4/24/2006
05-2876 HOPE OF SOUTHWEST FLORIDA, INC.  V. AGENCY FOR HEALTH CARE ADMINISTRATION AND HOSPICE OF NAPLES, INC. AFFIRMED 4/4/2006
05-2899 ERIC WAYNE MANNING v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 4/5/2006
05-2906 FLOWERS BAKERIES and ACE USA v. EDWARD HABER AFFIRMED 4/20/2006
05-2932 THEODORE WHITE v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 4/24/2006
05-2963 HENRY VANN v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 4/6/2002
05-2997 LARRY W. WALDROUPE v. FLORIDA UNEMPLOYMENT APPEALS COMMISSION AFFIRMED 4/6/2002
05-3040 JAMEL BROWN v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 4/21/2006
05-3087 RONALD E. BENBOE v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 4/26/2006
05-3106 DAVID MARCUM  v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 4/13/2006
05-3273 ARTHUR JAMES v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 4/28/2006
05-3294 GEORGE JONES v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 4/21/2006
05-3313 WILLIAM T. THACKER, JR. v. STATE OF FLORIDA 4/12/2006
05-3337 ORANGE COUNTY FIRE RESCUE and UNISOURCE ADMINISTRATORS, INC. v. MARY WILLIAMS AFFIRMED 4/21/2006
05-3355 ROBERT NELSON  v. CITY OF TAMPA AND COMMERCIAL RISK MANAGEMENT AFFIRMED 4/4/2006
05-3418 T.C., father of C.D., O.C. and S.C., children v. DEPARTMENT OF CHILDREN AND FAMILIES AFFIRMED 4/20/2006
05-3499 LUIS GURIDI v. FLORIDA PAROLE COMMISSION DENIED 4/24/2006
05-3517 AMERICAN NATIONAL PROPERTY AND CASUALTY COMPANY v. HUE NGUYEN, and wife, RIU NGUYEN 4/12/2006
05-3528 GARY W. GILLETTE v. JAMES R. McDONOUGH, Secretary, FLORIDA DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTIONS AFFIRMED 4/24/2006
05-3573 AL TAYLOR v. STATE OF FLORIDA 4/12/2006
05-3593 JOHNNIE BELL v. JAMES R. McDONOUGH DENIED ON MERITS 4/20/2006
05-3610 SAMMIE DUBBERLY v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 4/19/2006
05-3631 STEPHEN STOKES v. RACHEL STOKES AFFIRMED 4/19/2006
05-3659 KEVIN BROWN  v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 4/10/2006
05-3791 WILLIAM RICHARD HAND v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 4/20/2006
05-3797 BRIAN J. STACKEN v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 4/19/2006
05-3835 WINDSOR COOKS v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 4/20/2006
05-3904 CHARLES R. JOHNSON  v. STATE OF FLORIDA DENIED ON MERITS 4/4/2006
05-3928 GREG PLUMMER v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 4/21/2006
05-4143 LAMAR GRADDY v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 4/26/2006
05-4152 ROBERT C. FORBIS v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 4/28/2006
05-4206 JULIE SEAN ACUFF v. FLORIDA UNEMPLOYMENT APPEALS COMMISSION and ALLIED MARINE GROUP INC. AFFIRMED 4/21/2006
05-4227 KENNETH JOHNSON v. STATE OF FLORIDA 4/12/2006
05-4292 DEANNA JONES v. JOHN L. WINN, as Commissioner of Education 4/12/2006
05-4296 EDWARD FORD v. JAMES R. McDONOUGH, Secretary, DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTIONS DENIED ON MERITS 4/26/2006
05-4298 PATRICK S. SLACK  v.  STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 4/10/2006
05-4356 RAYFIELD LANE v. FLORIDA PAROLE COMMISSION DENIED ON MERITS 4/19/2006
05-4405 WILLIAM DEFREIS  v. JAMES R. MCDONOUGH, SECRETARY, FLORIDA DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTIONS DENIED ON MERITS 4/13/2006
05-4438 STEPHANIE A. BROWN v. STATE OF FLORIDA DENIED ON MERITS 4/21/2006
05-4443 ROBERT DALPHONSE v. FLORIDA UNEMPLOYMENT APPEALS COMMISSION AFFIRMED 4/4/2006
05-4448 LEO RAINS v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 4/20/2006
05-4455 JAMES E. BROWN v. FLORIDA PAROLE COMMISSION DENIED ON MERITS 4/24/2006
05-4458 RYAN ADAM MINGLEDORFF v. STATE OF FLORIDA DENIED ON MERITS 4/5/2006
05-4479 F.G.B., a child v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 4/24/2006
05-4484 CARLOS E. DORION v. SWISSPORT NORTH AMERICA and INSURANCE CO. of STATE of PA c/o AIG CLAIM SERVICES, INC. 4/12/2006
05-4493 DARRYL EUGENE ROBINSON  v. FLORIDA DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTIONS DENIED 4/4/2006
05-4515 WILLIAM HALE  v. JAMES R. MCDONOUGH, SECRETARY, FLORIDA DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTIONS AFFIRMED 4/10/2006
05-4529 VICTOR SMALL v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 4/5/2006
05-4585 KASSANDRA WILLIAMS v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 4/26/2006
05-4625 BARRY EDWARD MILLER v. FLORIDA PAROLE COMMISSION DENIED ON MERITS 4/19/2006
05-4630 DARON C. HOLMES  v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 4/13/2006
05-4642 RICHARD SMITH v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 4/10/2006
05-4657 CLIFF BLUNTSON v. JAMES R. McDONOUGH, SECRETARY, FLORIDA DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTIONS DENIED ON MERITS 4/21/2006
05-4714 STATE OF FLORIDA v. DOUGLAS DANNER AFFIRMED 4/24/2006
05-4717 UDO SINCLAIR McJOLLY v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 4/26/2006
05-4748 MICHAEL A. REYNOLDS v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 4/21/2006
05-4812 KEVIN D. D'HAITI v. JAMES R. MCDONOUGH, SECRETARY, FLORIDA DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTIONS DENIED 4/4/2006
05-4826 K.M., mother, In the Interest of K.M., a minor child v. DEPARTMENT OF CHILDREN AND FAMILIES 4/12/2006
05-4852 KENNETH TOMBERLIN WILDBERGER v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 4/5/2006
05-4899 ORREN A. LOUDER v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 4/26/2006
05-4917 JOHN F. CURRY, JR.  V. LUCY D. HADI, etc., et al. DENIED ON MERITS 4/13/2006
05-4943 STACEY M. WILLIAMS v. FLORIDA UNEMPLOYMENT APPEALS COMMISSION AFFIRMED 4/20/2006
05-4957 MICAH LAMB v. STATE OF FLORIDA 4/12/2006
05-4977 BETTY L. SPEERS, WIFE v. TIMOTHY R. SPEERS, HUSBAND AFFIRMED 4/26/2006
05-4985 R.G., a child v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 4/24/2006
05-4990/05-5066/05-5123 A.S., a child v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 4/20/2006
05-5058 RUSSELL F. TAPTICH v. CHRIS JONES, Escambia County Property Appraiser, and DAVID BRIGGS, Property Tax Administration Program Director, FLORIDA DEPARTMENT OF REVENUE AFFIRMED 4/26/2006
05-5104 ROBERT TABER v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 4/24/2006
05-5212 PETER E. PFLAUM v. THOMAS AND LEANNE PFLAUM AFFIRMED 4/26/2006
05-5247 BOBBY JO STARKER v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 4/5/2006
05-5255 GARY K. WILLIAMS v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 4/5/2006
05-5268 FRANKIE WHETSTONE v. STATE OF FLORIDA 4/12/2006
05-5282 NATHANIEL C. MCCLAIN v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 4/5/2006
05-5283 WILBUR KIRKLAND v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 4/24/2006
05-5309 GEORGE JOSEPH RODRIGUEZ v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 4/26/2006
05-5312 I.L., a child v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 4/26/2006
05-5321 T. S., A CHILD  v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 4/4/2006
05-5352 MARSHALL WASHINGTON v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 4/5/2006
05-5362 JEREMIAH BUTLER v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 4/26/2006
05-5369 JOSE QUINTERO  v. STATE OF FLORIDA  AFFIRMED 4/10/2006
05-5396 ALL FAITH DAY CARE CENTER and FELICIA ARMSTRONG v. STATE OF FLORIDA, DEPARTMENT OF CHILDREN AND FAMILY SERVICES, DON T. WINSTEAD, in his Official Capacity as Deputy Secretary, Department of Children and Families, and ANDREA J. TRZCINSKI, in her Official Capacity as Program Administrator, Department of Children and Families AFFIRMED 4/26/2006
05-5420 CHARLES C. WOODEN  v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 4/10/2006
05-5434 LARRY BELL  v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 4/13/2006
05-5449 ALLEN MELTON, JR., v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 4/10/2006