1DCA
MONTH: December 2006
To view full document click on case number (document in .pdf format)
Number Style Per Curiam Disposition Date Issued
03-0596 KELVIN R. JENKINS v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 12/13/2006
03-3251 KIP A. STERLING v. JAMES R. McDONOUGH, SECRETARY, FLORIDA DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTIONS DENIED 12/11/2006
04-4785 WALTER DAVIS v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 12/20/2006
04-5444 RALPH W. HOWARD v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 12/7/2006
05-0443 PHILLIP SANGSTER v. STATE OF FLORDIA  AFFIRMED 12/6/2006
05-2005 GEORGE W. GUYNN  v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 12/12/2006
05-2108 ANTONIO RODRIGUEZ  v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 12/22/2006
05-2534 FRANK MANSFIELD v. LUNDQUIST EXCAVATING INC. and CNA COMMERCIAL INSURANCE AFFIRMED 12/11/2006
05-2550 KEVIN LAMAR FOUNTAIN v. STATE OF FLORDIA AFFIRMED 12/6/2006
05-2666 KIRK RUSSELL KOSTENKO v. STATE OF FLORDIA AFFIRMED 12/6/2006
05-2955 SHANNA BOUCHER MATTEO v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 12/4/2006
05-3462 ROLAND HENDRICKSON v. STATE OF FLORDIA AFFIRMED 12/6/2006
05-3711 JOHN KNIGHT v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 12/11/2006
05-3736 LAWRENCE HUDSON  v.  STATE OF FLORIDA  AFFIRMED 12/22/2006
05-3742 ERNEST CONTRILLO v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 12/14/2006
05-3808 TEODORA AVILIA v. CRYSTAL BALL CLUB MANAGEMENT, and FHM INSURANCE COMPANY AFFIRMED 12/6/2006
05-3809 JAMMI KUPERSMITH, JR. v. NATIONAL AIRLINES and TRAVELERS INSURANCE COMPANY AFFIRMED 12/6/2006
05-3852 DEVONCHE LAWRENCE  v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 12/12/2006
05-3902 TERRANCE L. KIMBROUGH v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 12/1/2006
05-4013 MONICA MCTIERNAN  v. PINELLAS SUNCOAST TRANSIT AUTHORITY AND JOHNS EASTERN COMPANY AFFIRMED 12/27/2006
05-4048 KENNETH ERVIN FAIRLEY v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 12/1/2006
05-4134 STEPHEN J. LESTER v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 12/1/2006
05-4434 JAMES M. DAWSON v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 12/11/2006
05-4520 GARY LEE MOUNT v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 12/14/2006
05-4675 LARRY PRIDE, JR., v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 12/15/2006
05-4758 DUSTY LYNN SIMMONDS v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 12/20/2006
05-4888 JENNIFER A. ORTIZ v. FLORIDA UNEMPLOYMENT APPEALS COMMISSION and RIVERSIDE PEDIATRICS, P.A AFFIRMED 12/13/2006
05-4906 ERNEST RIGDON v. DIANA B. RIGDON AFFIRMED 12/19/2006
05-4914 RANDALL T. PRATER  v. JAMES R. MCDONOUGH DENIED 12/22/2006
05-4954 LEO C. HOLLINGSWORTH, JR. v. JAMES R. McDONOUGH AFFIRMED 12/20/2006
05-4989 MARK PAUL BEAL v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 12/11/2006
05-5089 PHILLIP K. ROBINSON v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 12/20/2006
05-5110 NORMAN WALKER v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 12/11/2006
05-5218 CHRISTOPHER NZE  v. LEWARE CONSTRUCTION CO. AND ZURICH-AMERICAN INSURANCE GROUP AFFIRMED 12/15/2006
05-5344 RONALD RICHARD LOWERY v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 12/18/2006
05-5368 JASON HUBBARD v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 12/4/2006
05-5403 IVORY MILES, JR. v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 12/7/2006
05-5544 JEROME GEE v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRM 12/8/2006
05-5570 COLUMBIA HOSPITAL and BROADSPIRE SERVICES, INC. v. TERESA MORALES AFFIRMED 12/7/2006
05-5589 TIMOTHY JONES v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 12/4/2006
05-5594 DAVID SHIPP  v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 12/12/2006
05-5608 RACHAEL ANNETTE KASCHAK v. STATE OF FLORDIA AFFIRMED 12/6/2006
05-5759 BARBARA G. BENSON v. SARASOTA COUNTY SCHOOL BOARD and INTEGRATED ADMINISTRATORS AFFIRMED 12/20/2006
05-5873 CATHIE DEMPSEY HOLBROOK v. HENRY LEON HOLBROOK, III AFFIRMED 12/14/2006
05-5895 LOUISE M.MALOY v. FLORIDA UNEMPLOYMENT APPEALS COMMISSION and CU PERSONNEL SOLUTIONS, INC. AFFIRM 12/8/2006
05-5903 DANIEL MENA v. ADP TOTAL SOURCE and UNITED SELF INSURED SERVICES AFFIRMED 12/14/2006
05-5916 RODNEY K. JORDAN v. THERESA D. JORDAN AFFIRMED 12/4/2006
05-5954 STATE OF FLORIDA v. HARRIET HUGHES WALLACE AFFIRMED 12/13/2006
05-6006 JONATHAN TOBIAS ALLEN v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 12/7/2006
05-6065 ACCORD HUMAN RESOURCES AND CAN CLAIMPLUS  v. JOSEPH E. TORRES AFFIRMED 12/22/2006
05-701 THOMAS COCHRANE v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 12/11/2006
06-0019 JESUS ACOSTA v. FEDERAL STAR CORPORATION and ASSOCIATED INDUSTRIES INSURANCE COMPANY, INC. AFFIRMED 12/6/2006
06-0084 DAVID P. KEVER v. JAMES R. McDONOUGH, SECRETARY, FLORIDA DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTIONS DENIED ON MERITS 12/4/2006
06-0126 ST. PAUL TRAVELERS and CENTRAL BREVARD HUMANE SOCIETY v. TAMMY KERR AFFIRMED 12/7/2006
06-0150/06-0151 BERNARD L. MITCHELL v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 12/7/2006
06-0166 ALFREDO VALLS  v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 12/12/2006
06-0231 CHRISTOPHER MOSLEY  v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 12/28/2006
06-0281 DONNA CARTER v. DECISION PEO, INC., and COMMERCIAL CLAIM SERVICES AFFIRMED 12/21/2006
06-0308 BENJAMIN McDONALD v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 12/20/2006
06-0348 ANDREW G. MOORE v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 12/21/2006
06-0381 JIMMY ROSIER v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 12/20/2006
06-0455 NATHANIEL HEATH v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 12/13/2006
06-0495 KEN ROBBIE HEAD v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 12/13/2006
06-0533 MARKEY CRUSE v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 12/1/2006
06-0538 JAMES GANEY v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 12/4/2006
06-0567 THOMAS VICTOR TURNER v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 12/7/2006
06-0568 WILLIE A. STROBRIDGE v. JAMES R. McDONOUGH DENIED 12/13/2006
06-0587 RINKER MATERIALS OF FLORIDA, INC., and CRAWFORD & COMPANY v. LOUISE ANZALONE AFFIRMED 12/7/2006
06-0636 MICHAEL WALLACE v. STATE OF FLORDIA AFFIRMED 12/6/2006
06-0661 MICHAEL CLINES  v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 12/22/2006
06-0669 ERIC J.MILLER v. JAMES R. McDONOUGH, SECRETARY, FLORIDA DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTIONS AFFIRM 12/8/2006
06-0702 ERIC E. BREEMEN v. SPACE GATEWAY SUPPORT and AIG CLAIM SERVICES AFFIRMED 12/6/2006
06-0762 AMANDA MOSLEY v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 12/19/2006
06-0789 HEMOPHILIA HEALTH SERVICES, INC.  v. STATE OF FLORIDA, AGENCY FOR HEALTH CARE ADMINISTRATION AFFIRMED 12/20/2006
06-0814 KATRINA L. BOGLE  v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 12/15/2006
06-0849 ROBERT L. MATTHEWS v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 12/20/2006
06-0863 JESSE A. EDWINS v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 12/14/2006
06-0890 MELISSA MARIE NOLET v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 12/20/2006
06-0932 DANIAL C. FINDLEY v. MARILYN STOKES FINDLEY AFFIRM 12/8/2006
06-0935 KRISSENA BROWN v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 12/19/2006
06-0941 THOMAS WIENECKE v. STATE OF FLORIDA  AFFIRMED 12/21/2006
06-0990 RODNEY CHRIS PARKER v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 12/20/2006
06-1158 JOHNNY JAMES TIMS v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 12/19/2006
06-1262 KIMBERLY BAUCOM v. FLORIDA UNEMPLOYMENT APPEALS COMMISSION and POLICY STUDIES, INC. AFFIRMED 12/19/2006
06-1269 CHRISTOPHER HUTCHINSON v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 12/21/2006
06-1279 LORA SHAFER v. FLORIDA UNEMPLOYMENT APPEALS COMMISSION, et al AFFIRM 12/8/2006
06-1314 GLADYS DUMERCY v. GRAND COURT LIFESTYLES and FIREMAN'S FUND INS. CO. AFFIRMED 12/20/2006
06-1345 VERNON SCHEIDER  v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 12/27/2006
06-1348 GERALD M. McKIRE v. JAMES R. McDONOUGH, SECRETARY, FLORIDA DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTIONS DENIED 12/4/2006
06-1383 VINCENT HICKS v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 12/13/2006
06-1410 EXPRESS PHONE SERVICE, INC. v. BELLSOUTH TELECOMMUNICATIONS, INC. AFFIRMED 12/6/2006
06-1416 JUAN A. ROSARIO v. STATE OF FLORIDA, DEPARTMENT OF BUSINESS AND PROFESSIONAL REGULATION, DIVISION OF PROFESSIONS AFFIRM 12/8/2006
06-1482 DANNY RAY FAIRCLOTH v. STATE OF FLORIDA DENIED ON THE MERITS 12/13/2006
06-1493 RICHARD GLENN CARTER v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 12/21/2006
06-1504 WILMER STRONG v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 12/14/2006
06-1510 GERALD JACKSON V. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRM 12/8/2006
06-1526 MARK D. HANNIFIN v. DEPARTMENT OF FINANCIAL SERVICES AFFIRMED 12/18/2006
06-1535 FLANDERS PRECISIONAIRE and FRANK GATES SERVICE COMPANY v. MARIA VENCES AFFIRMED 12/11/2006
06-1563 THE CHILDREN'S PALACE II v. DEPARTMENT OF CHILDREN AND FAMILY SERVICES AFFIRMED 12/20/2006
06-1623 JIMMY FISHER v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 12/18/2006
06-1642 THOMAS LAVELLE JENKINS v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 12/18/2006
06-1679 DENNIS THOMAS v. DARICE RENEE BECKER AFFIRMED 12/7/2006
06-1717 J.A., father of D.A., J.A., C.A. and B.C.A., minor children v. DEPARTMENT OF CHILDREN AND FAMILY SERVICES AFFIRMED 12/11/2006
06-1754 DOREEN CHRISTIAN v. VILLA MARIA NURSING and GALLAGHER BASSETT SERVICES, INC. AFFIRM 12/8/2006
06-1792 KERMITT WILLIAMS v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRM 12/8/2006
06-1795 WOODROW FAISON v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 12/11/2006
06-1887 KEITH L. JONES v. JAMES R. McDONOUGH AFFIRMED 12/4/2006
06-1906 YVONNE B. ROUSSEAU v. FLORIDA UNEMPLOYMENT APPEALS COMMISSION and FLORIDA HOSPITAL ASSOCIATION AFFIRMED 12/19/2006
06-1963 D.A., mother of D.A., J.A., C.A., B.C.A., minor children v. DEPARTMENT OF CHILDREN AND FAMILY SERVICES AFFIRMED 12/11/2006
06-198 SHELDON FORD v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 12/11/2006
06-2110 LEO C. HOLLINGSWORTH, JR. v. JAMES McDONOUGH DENIED 12/7/2006
06-2149 ROBERT ALLEN MORSE  v. JAMES R. MCDONOUGH, SECRETARY, FLORIDA DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTIONS DENIED ON MERITS 12/15/2006
06-2152 WILLIE BIVENS  v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 12/22/2006
06-2175 BENNIE E. SMITH  v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 12/7/2006
06-2216 JAMES NEWNAM  v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 12/12/2006
06-2220 HOWARD ROSENBLATT, attorney for MARION TOMPKINS as Personal Representative v. LEXYNE PAGE and HOWARD CLYATT, Blanche B. Clyett's Collateral Heirs, IN RE: The Estate of BLANCHE B. CLYATT, Deceased AFFIRMED 12/20/2006
06-2386 WILLIAM H. WILSON and DOROTHY C. WILSON, on behalf of other similarly situated persons v. FRANKLIN COUNTY, FLORIDA AND ALEXIS MARKETING COMPANY, INC. AFFIRMED 12/11/2006
06-2407 CAROL J. PADGETT v. SCHOOL BOARD OF ESCAMBIA COUNTY AFFIRMED 12/19/2006
06-2432 FLORIDA SURETY AGENTS ASSOCIATION, INC. v. DEPARTMENT OF FINANCIAL SERVICES & ATHENA SOLUTIONS, LLC AFFIRMED 12/4/2006
06-2489 A.B., a child  v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 12/7/2006
06-2542 EMMIT EASON v. JAMES R. McDONOUGH DENIED 12/7/2006
06-2579 M. J., a child v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 12/4/2006
06-2686 PATRICK D. BRADEN v. AILEEN TOCE AFFIRMED 12/6/2006
06-2690 SYLVESTER BUTLER v. DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTIONS DENIED ON MERITS 12/13/2006
06-2727 DAVIDE P. KEVER v. JAMES R. McDONOUGH, SECRETARY, DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTIONS DENIED ON THE MERITS 12/14/2006
06-2759 ANNETTE C. SCOTT, the mother and a survivor of Todd Barrett Myers v. THE ESTATE OF TODD BARRETT MYERS AFFIRMED 12/20/2006
06-2785 REX MIRES v. FLORIDA DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTIONS DENIED ON MERITS 12/18/2006
06-2867 ERNEST WATKINS v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 12/13/2006
06-2868 ANDRE WHITE v. FLORIDA PAROLE COMMISSION DISMISSED 12/14/2006
06-2887 D. D.R., A CHILD  v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 12/22/2006
06-296 RANDOLF JACKSON v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 12/11/2006
06-2983 JOHN REQUILMAN v. JAMES R. McDONOUGH, SECRETARY, FLORIDA DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTIONS AFFIRMED 12/7/2006
06-3051 RALPH LOVETTE, SR. v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 12/4/2006
06-3150 GENERAL JACKSON PRIDE v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 12/13/2006
06-3160 ROSETTA MARRA v. FLORIDA UNEMPLOYMENT APPEALS COMMISSION and MARCELLOS, INC. AFFIRMED 12/6/2006
06-3165 JAMES W. CRAIN, JR. v. STATE OF FLORIDA, DEPARTMENT OF FINANCIAL SERVICES DENIED 12/7/2006
06-3250 ORVEL LLOYD  v. STATE OF FLORIDA DENIED ON MERITS 12/12/2006
06-3286 E.M., the mother of W.P., a child v. FLORIDA DEPARTMENT OF CHILDREN AND FAMILIES AFFIRMED 12/11/2006
06-3332 KENNETH RAY POLK  v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 12/12/2006
06-3411 JAMES SANDS  v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 12/12/2006
06-3517 PETER ANTHONY ANTON v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 12/14/2006
06-3646 ALLEN MELTON, JR. v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 12/14/2006
06-3653 WILLIAM WARD v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 12/14/2006
06-3725 MARIO MONTGOMERY v. FLORIDA PAROLE COMMISSION DENIED ON MERITS 12/14/2006
06-3759 MICHAEL JEROME PAGE  v. FLORIDA PAROLE COMMISSION DENIED 12/28/2006
06-3809 MARGARET ROBINSON  v. PRENTICE I. ROBINSON AFFIRMED 12/22/2006
06-3993   AFFIRM 12/8/2006
06-4051 ROGER D. BUNGER v. FLORIDA DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTIONS AFFIRMED 12/19/2006
06-4052 THERESA M. BENDER, in her official capacity as the Chapter 7 Bankruptcy Trustee for Ridley Owens, Inc. v. JAMES L. RIDLEY, JR., individually, and TAYLOR COTTON & RIDLEY, INC. DENIED 12/7/2006
06-4090 JOE ANN MIDDLETON v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 12/4/2006
06-4101 ERIC GEAROD SCARLETT  v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 12/15/2006
06-4138 MACEO SIMPSON v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 12/14/2006
06-4153 STEVE CLAYTON VERMILLION  v. JAMES R. MCDONOUGH, SECRETARY, FLORIDA DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTIONS AFFIRMED 12/27/2006
06-4231 DEMARIO PRUITT v. STATE OF FLORDIA AFFIRMED 12/6/2006
06-4320 VERNON GOINS  v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 12/12/2006
06-4344 JAMES S. PENDERGRAFT, IV, M.D. v. DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH DENIED 12/14/2006
06-4385 RICHARD HALE v. STATE OF FLORIDA DENIED 12/4/2006
06-4397 ANTONIO JOHNSON v. JAMES R. McDONOUGH AFFIRMED 12/4/2006
06-4645 ELDRED FRAZIER v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 12/14/2006
06-4679 JOHN HUBBARD v. STATE OF FLORIDA, et al DENIED 12/14/2006
06-4680 DEUNIKLE WILLIAMS v. JAMES R. McDONOUGH, SECRETARY, FLORIDA DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTIONS DENIED 12/14/2006
06-4691 SIDDIQ B. A. ASAD v. JAMES R. McDONOUGH DENIED 12/6/2006
06-4699 LEONARD C. GEORGE v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 12/14/2006
06-4805 GEOFFREY L. OLIN v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 12/19/2006
06-4888 DAVID CHILDERS v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 12/13/2006
06-4891 STEVEN MICHAEL COOLEY  v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 12/15/2006
06-4901 SIDDIQ B. A. ASAD v. JAMES R. McDONOUGH DENIED ON MERITS 12/20/2006
06-4975 JULIO GUILLEN v. STATE OF FLORDIA DENIED 12/6/2006
06-5173 STEVE AUSTIN, JR. v. DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTIONS DENIED ON MERITS 12/20/2006
06-5255 ADMINISTAFF OF FLORIDA, INC., and UNITED SELF-INSURED SERVICES v. LAWRENCE D. CONGER DISMISSED 12/18/2006
06-528 STATE OF FLORIDA v. HENRY W. FAIN, JR. AFFIRMED 12/11/2006
06-5290 ANDREW GROVER v. STATE OF FLORIDA DENIED ON MERITS 12/13/2006
06-5326 DANIEL KEVIN SCHMIDT  v. STATE OF FLORIDA DENIED 12/15/2006
06-5341 JULIUS MCGRIFF  v. STATE OF FLORIDA DENIED ON MERITS 12/15/2006
06-5574 CHRISTOPHER PORTER v. STATE OF FLORIDA DISMISSED 12/20/2006
06-5609 EDWARD L. BROWN v. STATE OF FLORDIA DENIED 12/6/2006
06-5899 ISSAC BROWN  v. JAMES R. MCDONOUGH, SECRETARY, FLORIDA DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTIONS DENIED 12/12/2006
06-6003 HAROLD B. PATE v. FLORIDA PAROLE COMMISSION DENIED 12/14/2006
06-6004 ANTHONY W. BROOM  v. STATE OF FLORIDA, et al. DENIED 12/15/2006
06-6006 RONALD MAYS  v. STATE OF FLORIDA DENIED 12/15/2006
06-6089 ROLAND THACKER v. STATE OF FLORIDA DENIED ON MERITS 12/20/2006
06-834 GLENN SCHOFIELD v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 12/11/2006
06-899 SHEDRICK BROWN v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 12/11/2006