1DCA
MONTH: October 2006
To view full document click on case number (document in .pdf format)
Number Style Per Curiam Disposition Date Issued
03-4013 AARON HARRIS HOLLEY, SR. v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 10/17/2006
04-1141 BILLY DALE SCHIMMEL v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 10/19/2006
04-4808 ROBERT D. McCOLLUM v. M. RATHMAN, WARDEN FLORIDA STATE PRISON DENIED 10/25/2006
04-4882 CARL MULLINGS v. JAMES R. McDONOUGH, Secretary, Florida Department of Corrections AFFIRMED 10/24/2006
05-0441 ROBERT EARL WILLIAMS  v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 10/11/2006
05-1798 PAUL KENNETH PILONE v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 10/30/2006
05-1947 CROWNE PARTNERS d/b/a CARRIAGE HOUSE APARTMENTS v. BILLY STOKES AFFIRMED 10/5/2006
05-2218 KENNETH MARK SINGLETON v. PAUL VAUGHN SIMS AFFIRMED 10/20/2006
05-2359 JOHN KEMP  v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 10/18/2006
05-2402 JOHN ALLEN ANDERSON v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 10/10/2006
05-2441 JULIO CESAR MONTOYA v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 10/20/2006
05-2479 VIRGINIA TOOKE v. FLORIDA UNEMPLOYMENT APPEALS COMMISSION and CIRCLE K. STORES, INC. AFFIRMED 10/23/2006
05-2513 JIMMY MCKNIGHT v. FLORIDA PAROLE COMMISSION DENIED 10/24/2006
05-2898 SHARON PHILLIPS v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 10/27/2006
05-3047 JAMES TURNER v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 10/20/2006
05-3096 SUZANNE MINUCCI v. UNITED PARCEL SERVICE, INC. AND LIBERTY MUTUAL INSURANCE COMPANY AFFIRMED 10/18/2006
05-3230 FELIX PEREZ v. FLORIDA PAROLE COMMISSION AFFIRMED 10/30/2006
05-3295 WILLIE DAVENPORT v. WAL-MART STORES, INC. and INTEGRATED ADMINISTRATORS AFFIRMED 10/6/2006
05-3322 ELISEO MARTINEZ v. SMART PAYROLL SOLUTIONS, INC./ LIBERTY MUTUAL GROUP AFFIRMED 10/19/2006
05-3348 KATHY CARTER v. FIRST CHOICE FOOD SERVICES d/b/a DUNKIN DONUTS and PINNACLE BENEFITS AFFIRMED 10/12/2006
05-3557 RICKY SWEET v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 10/12/2006
05-3642 LAWRENCE ERIK RICHARDS v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 10/10/2006
05-3733 LUZ GONZALEZ v. HAV-A-TAMPA and HARTFORD INSURANCE CO. AFFIRMED 10/24/2006
05-3757 JOYCELYN GUTHRIE v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 10/6/2006
05-3786 MICHAEL WANZER v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 10/12/2006
05-3801 JAMES BALKCOM v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 10/6/2006
05-3862 FRANCOIS PIERRE  v. CITY OF NORTH MIAMI BEACH/SUMMIT CLAIMS CENTER AFFIRMED 10/18/2006
05-3929 FABRICIO GOMEZ v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 10/19/2006
05-3932 PETER JOSEPH KLAUER v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 10/27/2006
05-3933 KENDALL EDWARD LEE KING v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 10/23/2006
05-3938/05-4668 EVA WELCH LITTIER v. MILLER, KAGAN, RODRIGUEZ & SILVER, UNITED SELF-INSURED SERVICES AFFIRMED 10/19/2006
05-3975 ROBERT L. BARKER v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 10/10/2006
05-4184 MELVIN L. SAMSON v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 10/17/2006
05-4244 CRYSTAL HALL v. STEVEN SIMMONS  AFFIRMED 10/31/2006
05-4252 JOHN FLOYD KITTRELL v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 10/19/2006
05-4262 CHRISTOPHER G. HARRELL v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 10/10/2006
05-4277 STEVE DELANO BROWN v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 10/31/2006
05-4339 BEVERLY ELROD v. THE UNIVERSITY OF WEST FLORIDA AFFIRMED 10/19/2006
05-4350 RAYMOND MICHAEL REESE v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 10/24/2006
05-4451 TIMES PUBLISHING COMPANY v. HCA HEALTH SERVICES OF FLORIDA, d/b/a REGIONAL MEDICAL CENTER BAYONET POINT AFFIRMED 10/13/2006
05-4488 ALONZO LEON MURRAY v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 10/10/2006
05-4653 CARL R. GARRETT v. RANDIE R. GARRETT AFFIRMED 10/13/2006
05-4679 CHARLES DAVIS  v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 10/18/2006
05-4773 DESHONE REED v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 10/31/2006
05-4778 WILLIE LEE HARPER v. JAMES R. McDONOUGH, SECRETARY, FLORIDA DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTIONS AFFIRMED 10/4/2006
05-4834 JOSEPH FORREST v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 10/10/2006
05-4855 BRANDON MASON v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 10/27/2006
05-4886 GREGORY C. CLARK v. STATE OF FLORIDA, JAMES R. McDONOUGH, SECRETARY FLORIDA DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTIONS, and FLORIDA PAROLE COMMISSION DENIED 10/25/2006
05-4893 RAMS PHARMACY, INC. d/b/a MORENO PHARMACY  v.  AGENCY FOR HEALTH CARE ADMINISTRATION AFFIRMED 10/18/2006
05-4923 WILLIE JAMES RICHARDSON v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 10/26/2006
05-4930 FRANK MITCHELL v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 10/10/2006
05-4933 VILMA LLORENTE v. PANAMSAT and ST. PAUL TRAVELERS CLAIM SERVICES AFFIRMED 10/31/2006
05-4950 HENRY LEE MCGOLEY v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 10/23/2006
05-4972 JOHNNY W. THOMAS v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 10/13/2006
05-5005 TOMY LEE BYRD v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 10/13/2006
05-5017 LILLO'S RESTAURANT, INC., v. MARINA MANAGEMENT CORPORATION, A FLORIDA CORPORATION FOR PROFIT, AND STEVE LILLO, AN INDIVIDUAL AFFIRMED 10/18/2006
05-5021 THOMAS ELLIOT MEEK, husband v. ANNE MARIE MEIRING, wife AFFIRMED 10/12/2006
05-5120 CARLETHA PURIFOY v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 10/25/2006
05-5200 STEPHEN LYTLE BEAR LYTLE v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 10/26/2006
05-5267 WENDY'S INTERNATIONAL, INC., and ACE USA v. TERESA SOCARRAS AFFIRMED 10/23/2006
05-5308 ROY GREGORY CLARK v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 10/12/2006
05-5371 CHARLES D. TAYLOR v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 10/17/2006
05-5378 SHAUNA HICKS CROES v. UNIVERSITY COMMUNITY HOSPITAL and SENTRY INSURANCE COMPANY AFFIRMED 10/31/2006
05-5405 JAMES PATRICK BONIFAY v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 10/6/2006
05-5416 MICHAEL DEAN MASTIN v. HON. THOMAS GALLAGHER, CHIEF FINANCIAL OFFICER, FLORIDA DEPARTMENT OF FINANCIAL SERVICES AFFIRMED 10/23/2006
05-5491 SOLUTIA, INC./BROADSPIRE v. FANNIE N. RANALDSON AFFIRMED 10/25/2006
05-5502 ANGELIKA PAYOUTE v. FLORIDA CRYSTALS CORP. a/k/a SUGAR FARMS & BROADSPIRE AFFIRMED 10/24/2006
05-5515 KEATH JOHNSON v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 10/17/2006
05-5553 DON SHULA'S HOTEL and THE HARTFORD v. JOSE FAJARDO AFFIRMED 10/24/2006
05-5624 S.W., mother v. S.B. AFFIRMED 10/10/2006
05-5626 ALEXANDER ROBINSON v. JAMES R. McDONOUGH, Secretary, Florida Department of Corrections DENIED 10/12/2006
05-5642 MAURICIO KYLER v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 10/25/2006
05-5694 TAVILIA PIERRE v. FLORIDA CRYSTALS CORP. a/k/a SUGAR FARMS & BROADSPIRE AFFIRMED 10/24/2006
05-5701 STEVEN BERNARDA POWELL v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 10/31/2006
05-5730 KEVIN D'ANNUNZIO v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 10/19/2006
05-5737 AMS STAFF LEASING, INC., UNION TEMPORARY SERVICES, INC., PROVIDENCE PROPERTY & CASUALTY INSURANCE COMPANY AND ASPEN ADMINISTRATORS v. WILLIAM FINNERAN AFFIRMED 10/27/2006
05-5792 DAVID ROBINSON v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 10/27/2006
05-5849 STEPHEN MARK PORTER a/k/a MARK PORTER v. JOSEPH M. COUREY and BOBBI L. COUREY AFFIRMED 10/30/2006
05-5851 THOMAS SWANSON v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 10/10/2006
05-5934 SYLVIA PATRICIA MATHIS v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 10/30/2006
05-5968 AZEEM TEART v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 10/12/2006
05-5989 AGNA J. HERBERT, III v. WG YATES & SONS CONSTRUCTION and RISK ENTERPROSE MANAGEMENT AFFIRMED 10/27/2006
05-6027 JOSEPH HICKS v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 10/13/2006
05-6033 STEVEN MCCAY, JR. v. AIRCO MECHANICAL and AMCOMP PINNACLE AFFIRMED 10/10/2006
05-6083 SHANE SUTTON v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 10/17/2006
05-6145 REINALDO DIAZ v. SUGAR FARMS CO-OP and BROADSPIRE AFFIRMED 10/30/2006
05-6163 LINDA GANT WHEELER v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 10/4/2006
05-6180 MARK McGUIRE v. QUALITY STEEL FABRICATION and BRIDGEFIELD EMPLOYERS INSURANCE COMPANY AFFIRMED 10/10/2006
06-0011 DANIEL C. MEDBERRY v. JAMES R. McDONOUGH, Secretary, Florida Department of Corrections DENIED 10/27/2006
06-0067 JAGADA KENYATTA CHAMBERS v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 10/10/2006
06-0147 FLORENCE BASON v. WAFFLE HOUSE, INC. AFFIRMED 10/24/2006
06-0161 RICHARD NYKAMP v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 10/5/2006
06-0216 NATHANIEL C. McCLAIN v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 10/13/2006
06-0277 VICTOR U. CHAMPAGNE v. DEPARTMENT OF REVENUE, CHILD SUPPORT ENFORCEMENT AFFIRMED 10/26/2006
06-0295 TRUDY JOHNSON v. ROGER CLEMMONS QUALITY AUTO SALES, INC. AFFIRMED 10/25/2006
06-0359 CURTIS PARKER v. JAMES R. McDONOUGH, Secretary, Florida Department of Corrections DENIED 10/30/2006
06-0367 TERYY DENARD SMITH v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 10/23/2006
06-0390 L.G., FATHER OF O.G., a child v. DEPARTMENT OF CHILDREN AND FAMILIES AFFIRMED 10/27/2006
06-0404 DANIEL C. MEDBERRY v. JAMES R. McDONOUGH, SECRETARY, FLORIDA DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTIONS DENIED 10/23/2006
06-0430 KENNETH HOLDRIDGE v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 10/31/2006
06-0453 LEW ALCINDER FOWLER v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 10/31/2006
06-0454 Dennis Dodge, Leigha Rae Feyen, Leonard Paul Hebb, Christina Inserillo, Janice Overturf, Laura Deagle, Sunny Wood, Clifton Jones, Richard Lucas and Robert Klaproth, Jr v. FLORIDA DEPARTMENT OF LAW ENFORCEMENT AFFIRMED 10/25/2006
06-0456 ANTHONY J. PETERSON v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 10/20/2006
06-0549 MARK BOYD v. FLORIDA SUN CONTROL PRODUCTS AND LIBERTY MUTUAL INSURANCE COMPANY AFFIRMED 10/27/2006
06-0563 CRAIG LYDELL LEE v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 10/12/2006
06-0586 JOHN CHARLES SUMNER v. EVA B. SUMNER AFFIRMED 10/24/2006
06-0615 DAVIDA PARKS v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 10/20/2006
06-0656 BUDDY ALAN SIGMON v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 10/4/2006
06-0663 BILLIE RUTH GRAHAM v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 10/13/2006
06-0683 LATWANDA W. MCAFFEE v. FLORIDA UNEMPLOYMENT APPEALS COMMISSION and LARGO HEALTH CARE ASSOCIATES, LLC. AFFIRMED 10/26/2006
06-0693 WILLIE PARKER v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 10/6/2006
06-0707 JULIO SICAJAN v. COX LUMBER CO. and FIRST LIBERTY INSURANCE CORPORATION AFFIRMED 10/5/2006
06-0743 SANFORD PAUL BUTLER v. JAMES R. McDONOUGH, INTERIM SECRETARY OF FLORIDA DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTIONS, et al. DENIED 10/30/2006
06-0767 ROBERT G. MORRIS and VIRGINIA S. MORRIS v. JACKSON COUNTY, a political subdivision of the State of Florida AFFIRMED 10/12/2006
06-0817 STATE OF FLORIDA, DEPARTMENT OF ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION v. FLORIDA PETROLEUM MARKETERS AND CONVENIENCE STORE ASSOCIATION AFFIRMED 10/30/2006
06-0837 CITIZENS PROPERTY INSURANCE CORPORATION v. ATCHISON PROPERTIES, INC. v. ATCHISON PROPERTIES, INC. AFFIRMED 10/17/2006
06-0842 MICHAEL V. INMAN v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 10/17/2006
06-0876 LEE D. KENNEDY v. FLORIDA UNEMPLOYMENT APPEALS COMMISSION and TRAWICK CONSTRUCTION AFFIRMED 10/23/2006
06-0895 NORTH FLORIDA MEDICAL CENTERS, INC. v. LARRY APPLEBEE AFFIRMED 10/24/2006
06-0912 BOBBY KEVIN WILLIAMS v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 10/27/2006
06-0917 MELVA RITA MEYER and ISRAEL G. SEEGER, as Personal Representative of the Estate of MARK KLAUSER v. WILLIAM M. ATKINSON, JR., as Personal Representative of the Estate of SAMUEL EMANUEL KLAUSER, Deceased, and THE CAPITAL TRUST COMPANY OF DELAWARE AFFIRMED 10/19/2006
06-0968 MARK L. CRUSAW v. STATE OF FLORIDA DENIED ON MERITS 10/10/2006
06-1032 FELIX McMILLIAN v. STATE OF FLORIDA DENIED ON MERITS 10/12/2006
06-1045 ALVIN JOEL COOPER v. SCOTTY'S HARDWARE and OHIO CASUALTY INSURANCE COMPANY AFFIRMED 10/31/2006
06-1082 JOHN ROBERT CHANDLER, III v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 10/25/2006
06-1106 THOMAS LACKER v. FLORIDA UNEMPLOYMENT APPEALS COMMISSION and AMERICAN BUSINESS SYSTEMS, INC. AFFIRMED 10/24/2006
06-1112 ROLLIE L. BAKER v. JAMES R. McDONOUGH, Secretary, Florida Department of Corrections DENIED ON MERITS 10/31/2006
06-1119 FLORIDA DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION, DISTRICT 4, AND FLORIDA DEPARTMENT OF FINANCIAL SERVICES/DIVISION OF RISK MANAGEMENT v. RALPH PACIELLO AFFIRMED 10/19/2006
06-1123 DANIEL BOONE v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 10/19/2006
06-1154 AMOS B. DICKEY v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 10/10/2006
06-1155 BRADLEY ARTHUR TRAVIS v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 10/6/2006
06-1156 STATE OF FLORIDA v. JOSHUA ELWELL  DENIED 10/17/2006
06-1157 KEITH BARBER v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 10/6/2006
06-1221 WALTER GORDON v. JAMES R. McDONOUGH, FLORIDA DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTIONS DENIED 10/19/2006
06-1296 Y.L., Mother of B.K., a minor child v. DEPARTMENT OF CHILDREN AND FAMILIES AFFIRMED 10/10/2006
06-1339 JOEY WASHINGTON v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 10/6/2006
06-1371 GALVESTER DANIELS v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 10/10/2006
06-1375 JOSEPH WHITE v. JAMES R. McDONOUGH DENIED ON MERITS 10/31/2006
06-1408 JIMMY KLINE v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 10/26/2006
06-1422 FLORIDA POWER & LIGHT COMPANY AND HELMSMAN MANAGEMENT SERVICES, INC v. WILLIAM MYERS AFFIRMED 10/25/2006
06-1452 HASE VUKALIC v. FLORIDA UNEMPLOYMENT APPEALS COMMISSION and GARELICK MFG, CO. AFFIRMED 10/27/2006
06-1487 JAMES ALLEN DAVIS v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 10/23/2006
06-1507 CATHERINE MULLEN v. JAMES MAXWELL DISMISSED 10/12/2006
06-1544 J.L.T.M., a child v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 10/20/2006
06-1589 JAMES E. DICKS v. STATE OF FLORIDA, DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTIONS AND DIVISION OF RISK MANAGEMENT AFFIRMED 10/13/2006
06-1611 DARRELL STANDBERRY v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 10/31/2006
06-1629 PATRICK HENRY BROWN v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 10/20/2006
06-1635 NICHOLAS BRADWELL v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 10/26/2006
06-1647 FRANK ALBERT DEKKER v. STATE OF FLORIDA DISMISSED 10/10/2006
06-1652 DONNIE LEE SALTER v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 10/19/2006
06-1657 AVIS RENT-A-CAR SYSTEM, INC. v. TARA D. HEWITT DENIED 10/27/2006
06-1660 WILLIAM B. SINGLETON v. JAMES R. McDONOUGH, Secretary, Florida Department of Corrections DENIED ON MERITS 10/30/2006
06-1697 SCOTT S. DOUGLAS v. FLORIDA UNEMPLOYMENT APPEALS COMMISSION AFFIRMED 10/24/2006
06-1700/06-1701 STATE OF FLORIDA v. A.G., a child AFFIRMED 10/17/2006
06-1707 JAMES PENN v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 10/27/2006
06-1710 ESTHER F. HOLMAN v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 10/13/2006
06-1712 TONY B. ROBINSON v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 10/26/2006
06-1720 JOHN H. HILL, JR. v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 10/4/2006
06-1737 JOHN MCKAY v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 10/6/2006
06-1748 TRAVIS S. CALHOUN v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 10/26/2006
06-1768/06-1770 EDWARD LEE SHARPE v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 10/19/2006
06-1785 GEORGE STALLWORTH v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 10/6/2006
06-1812 DERRICK L. CUMMINGS v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 10/27/2006
06-1824 WAYNE SEYMOUR v. FLORIDA PAROLE COMMISSION DENIED 10/10/2006
06-1860 ANTONIO BENITO COLEMAN v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 10/27/2006
06-1863 MICHAEL DREW v. STEVEN F. SINGER, THE WARDEN, COLUMBIA CORRECTIONAL INSTITUTION AFFIRMED 10/31/2006
06-1878 KATHLEEN KOSZOLA v. FLORIDA UNEMPLOYMENT APPEALS COMMISSION AND PALM BEACH COUNTY SCHOOL BOARD AFFIRMED 10/31/2006
06-1890 JOHN L. CREWS v. STATE OF FLORIDA AFFIRMED 10/17/2006